Dave (Karan Soni) receives a package at his home, opening it to find a stuffed wolf and DVD titled, "Watch Me," which shows unsettling shots of the inside of his house filmed by someone whistling a cheerful tune. Josef (now going by the name of Aaron) (Mark Duplass) knocks on the door. Dave greets him as a friend and they discuss the disturbing video. While Dave is in the kitchen, Aaron gestures and grins toward the stuffed wolf.